The term “periodontal disease” define a group of problems affecting the tissues surrounding the tooth, which induce gingival bleeding and retraction of soft tis- sues and may result in bone loss due to inflammation induced by bacteria contamination. The diagnosis of the disease and its grade of severity is based on the evaluation of clinical parameters such as probing depth (PD), clinical attachment level (CAL) and recession (REC). As previously demonstrated in several in vitro and in vivo studies, reproducibility of the measurements of the probing depth is
dependent on the examiner’s abilities and experience. The purpose of this comparative study is to evaluate the consistency and reproducibility of the measurements detected by two examiners with different levels of experience in patients with periodontitis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted on 25 patients. All measurements were taken on the right jaw for a minimum of 36 probing sites for each subject included in the research. The same teeth were alternately examined and evaluated by two operators and the order for the examination was randomly determined based on a table generated by a computer. The probing was performed with a North Carolina periodontal probe and the following parameters were recorded: PD, REC, furcation and mobility. The two operators were an experienced dentist with ten- year experience in periodontology (SC) and a dental hygienist (FG) with a year of experience in periodontology.
RESULTS
The Cohen’s Kappa showed a fair agreement (0.376) in the identification of sites with probing depth equal or higher than 4 mm, and a moderate agreement in the identification of teeth with at least one site with probing depth equal or higher than 4 mm.
CONCLUSIONS
The present study showed the presence of discrepancies in probing results when two operators with different experience and background evaluate the same periodontal site. The reproducibility of periodontal evaluation has been studied in several in vivo and in vitro researches, however, no studies are completely superimposable to the present work. The importance of a careful calibration process in order to increase the reproducibility of the periodontal evaluation was highlighted in the study published by Andrade et al. in 2012. The authors affirmed that the reproducibility of the results could be mostly influenced by the previous calibration of the operators and the exercise more than the operators’ experience. This result can be considered as a partial confirmation of the results obtained in our study, where the relatively poor reproducibility of the results can be explained by the absence of calibration. However, these findings are in contrast with that obtained by other authors that considered operators experience the key factor to obtain reproducible measurements. To conclude, only moderate accordance could be obtained for both PD and CAL values when two operators with different levels of experience are considered.
CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE
The study showed that it is difficult to obtain a complete accordance in the periodontal parameters evaluation when two differ- ent experienced operators are selected. A calibration period can be considered necessary in order to obtain reproducible measurements for PD and CAL. More randomized clinical trials should consider the effects of calibration methods on reproducibility of clinical parameters measurement.
Aggressive periodontitis is a destructive disease characterized by the following: the involvement of multiple teeth with a distinctive pattern of periodontal tissue loss; a high rate of disease...
Periodontology 09 April 2025
Periodontitis is a chronic inflammatory non-communicable disease (NCD) characterised by the destruction of the tooth-supporting apparatus (periodontium), including alveolar bone, the presence of...
Periodontology 21 February 2025
Periodontology 08 November 2024
Microbiology in Diagnosis and Treatment of Severe Periodontitis. A Report of Four Cases
The purpose of this report is to illustrate the use of microbiology in the diagnosis and treatment in four cases of severe adult periodontitis.
Endodontics 21 September 2023
The authors previously demonstrated that auxiliary metformin therapy promotes healing of apical periodontitis. Here, the team aimed to investigate the effects of metformin on osteoblast...
Products 19 November 2026
FDA Grants Breakthrough Designation to OraLiva Oral Cancer Test
Investigational cytology test is designed to help clinicians assess suspicious oral lesions with a quantitative index.
News 19 November 2026
The Delta Dental Community Care Foundation, the philanthropic arm of Delta Dental of California and its affiliates, announced $16.3 million in Access to Care Grant funding, continu
News 19 November 2026
Henry Schein Announces Upcoming Investor Conference Presentations
(Nasdaq: HSIC), the world’s largest provider of healthcare solutions to office-based dental and medical practitioners, announced today that the Company will present at the followin
Editorials 19 November 2026
Twenty Florida high school students recently visited the UF College of Dentistry, or UFCD, for a day of programming designed to help them explore potential careers in dentistry.
Periodontology 19 November 2026
This peer-reviewed periodontology article summarizes clinical evidence from Journal of periodontology (2026). It focuses on findings that may help dental professionals evaluate treatment decisions,...