HOME - Clinical cases - Oral surgery
 
 
23 January 2019

Socket sealing post-extractive with xenogenic porcine collagen matrix: a prospective clinical trial

Co-authors: A. L. Rossi, V. Capilupi, D. Palombo - Department of biomedical, surgical and dental sciences, Università degli studi di Milano, ASST Santi Paolo e Carlo, Clinical Unit of Oral Surgery

Matteo Chiapasco


INTRODUCTION 
Tooth extraction is associated with a significant alteration of the soft tissues surrounding the post-extraction alveolus. The alveolar bone crest preservation techniques are used in clinical practice to reduce the volumetric bone contraction that occurs as a result of the avulsion of a dental element and, at the same time, to restore the correct profile of hard and soft tissues. Within these techniques, different research activities have focused on the development of new materials and new surgical techniques, useful for the increase and preservation of the keratinized mucous tissue positioned around the rehabilitations on implants.
The objective of this prospective cohort study is to test the performance of a new xenogenic collagen matrix as a socket sealing material, to allow second-intention healing of post-extractive sockets filled with a xenogenic bone substitute or with an immediate submerged implant. 

MATERIALS AND METHODS 
10 patients were recruited, presenting a single-rooted tooth scheduled for extraction. After atraumatic tooth removal, the post-extractive alveolus received either a socket preservation procedure or an immediate submerged implant. In both cases, the gingival margins of the alveolus were sealed with a xenogenic collagen matrix (Mucoderm, Botiss Dental, Zossen, Germany). The following parameters were evaluated:

  • exposed surface of the matrix at the end of surgery (T0);
  • soft tissue healing at 1, 4, 6, and 8 weeks from surgery (T1-4);
  • histological aspect of gingiva samples, harvested 20 weeks after surgery (T5); 
  • aesthetic performance provided by the socket sealing material (T4).     

RESULTS 
The results of the study showed that:

  • the mean post-operative exposure area of the matrix was 26.25 mm2 (14.2 to 38.84 mm2 );
  • 8 weeks after surgery, full wound closure was achieved in 9 out of 10 sites with healthy keratinized tissue;
  • the histological evaluation of gingiva sample revealed the presence of healthy keratinized gingival tissue, with no signs of aberrations or anomalies;
  • the mean colorimetric score ∆E between the regenerated site and the surrounding gingiva was 3.76 (3 to 6.55).

Seven out of 10 patients reported an excellent aesthetic integration of the matrix (∆E < 3.7). 

CONCLUSIONS 
Preliminary results from this study suggest that this new xenogenic porcine-derived collagen matrix could represent a valuable alternative to allow second intention healing of post-extractive sockets filled with a xenogenic bone substitute or with an immediate submerged implant. New randomized clinical trials are needed to confirm the preliminary results obtained in the study and evaluate the long-term benefits.  

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE 
The alveolar bone crest preservation techniques are used in clinical practice to reduce the volumetric bone contraction that occurs as a result of the avulsion of a dental element and, at the same time, to restore the correct profile of hard and soft tissues. In the present study, the use of the xenogenic matrix in collagen, in the coverage of a post-extraction site, seem to allow a correct regeneration and integration of the keratinized gingival tissue overlying the alveolus, both from a biological and an aesthetic point of view. However, the lack of consolidated scientific evidence regarding this technique requires the execution of new randomized clinical trials, aimed at confirming the results obtained, evaluating their long-term benefits. 


For additional information: 
Dental Cadmos n° 05/2018 - https://doi.org/10.19256/d.cadmos.05.2018.06

  • Fig. 1 Initial situation, clinical picture, frontal view. The element 2.1 results seriously compromised. We decided to proceed to its avulsion and then with implant-prosthetic rehabilitation.

    Fig. 1 Initial situation, clinical picture, frontal view. The element 2.1 results seriously compromised. We decided to proceed to its avulsion and then with implant-prosthetic rehabilitation.

  • Fig. 2 Initial situation, periapical intraoral radiography, insufficient root size and contraindication of element recovery

    Fig. 2 Initial situation, periapical intraoral radiography, insufficient root size and contraindication of element recovery

  • Fig. 3 Post-extractive alveolus; minimally invasive avulsion, frontal vision

    Fig. 3 Post-extractive alveolus; minimally invasive avulsion, frontal vision

  • Fig. 4 Biomaterial grafting into the alveolus; it will provide support for soft tissues above

    Fig. 4 Biomaterial grafting into the alveolus; it will provide support for soft tissues above

  • Fig. 5 Post-extraction socket cover using the collagen matrix, adapted to the alveolar morphology and covered, for at least 2/3 of its surface, from the mucous flap, without periosteal incisions

    Fig. 5 Post-extraction socket cover using the collagen matrix, adapted to the alveolar morphology and covered, for at least 2/3 of its surface, from the mucous flap, without periosteal incisions

  • Fig. 6 Stabilization of the mucosal flap and of the matrix through stitches in nylon 5/0. The size of the exposed matrix surface is highlighted

    Fig. 6 Stabilization of the mucosal flap and of the matrix through stitches in nylon 5/0. The size of the exposed matrix surface is highlighted

  • Fig. 7 Clinical check at 8 weeks from the intervention. Front view. In evidence the perfect aesthetic integration of the newly formed keratinized tissue with the surrounding tissue

    Fig. 7 Clinical check at 8 weeks from the intervention. Front view. In evidence the perfect aesthetic integration of the newly formed keratinized tissue with the surrounding tissue

  • Fig. 8 Clinical check at 8 weeks from the intervention. Occlusal view. The perfect aesthetic integration of the keratinized tissue is highlighted newly formed with the surrounding tissue

    Fig. 8 Clinical check at 8 weeks from the intervention. Occlusal view. The perfect aesthetic integration of the keratinized tissue is highlighted newly formed with the surrounding tissue

Related articles

Odontogenic keratocyst (OKC), also known as keratoconus odontogenic tumor, is locally aggressive and frequently relapses, with most relapses occurring within 5 years of treatment. It originates...


The connective tissue graft (CTG) is considered the material of choice in treating gingival or mucosal recessions around teeth and implants. Nowadays it is...


Panoramic radiography, also known as orthopantomography (OPG), is commonly used in facial and dental pain investigations. This radiographic modality shows the...


Impacted third molars are directly or indirectly the underlying cause of numerous disorders in the mouth, jaw and facial regions like:  pericoronitis...


Maxillary sinus elevation has been shown to be a safe and effective means of creating adequate vital bone formation for implant placement in pneumatized ...


Read more

In orthodontics, the archform is considered to be important mainly for stability, occlusion, and esthetics. Archform tends to return toward the pretreatment ...


Authors: G. Mergoni, I. Giovannacci, G. Giunta, G. Ghidini, M. Meleti, M. Manfredi, P. Vescovi

An 11-year-old patient  was sent to out observation by her pediatrician for a maxillary gingival lesion that had arisen about 2 months earlier and...


Many dental procedures can be performed with local anesthesia. Nonetheless in certain clinical situation and especially with pediatric patients it can be...


Zirconia implants have been brought to the dental market as a viable alternative to titanium implants initially to fulfill a demand from patients for...


Is it better to try to preserve a dental element with every possible means or to place an osseointegrated implant? There is a great variability of response...


 
 

Newsletter

 
 
 
 

Most popular

 
 

Events