HOME - Clinical cases - Implantology
 
 
16 July 2019

Fracture of zirconia implants

Lara Figini


Zirconia implants have been brought to the dental market as a viable alternative to titanium implants initially to fulfill a demand from patients for non-metallic materials. Although zirconia is less tough than titanium, the fracture of zirconia implants seems to be a rare event but still important to analyze, as it can provide useful information on issues related to the design of the plant, to the diameter and to the treatment of the surface. Among the most probable causes cited for zirconia implant fracture are unfavorable narrow diameters, damaging surface treatments resulting from aggressive alumina sandblasting, and patient-related overloading.           

MATERIAL AND METHODS 
In a study published on Dental Materials in February 2019, the authors performed fractographic analyzes of 15 parts of fractured zirconia implants (11 posterior and 4 anterior) with their integral ceramic crowns still cemented on them. The implants were first generations from four manufacturers (AXIS Biodental, Z-Systems, Straumann, Swiss Dental Solutions). The time-to-failure varied between 2 weeks and 9 years. The fractography was performed by identifying the origin of the failure and the characteristics of the superficial fracture. From 2D and 3D digital images of the crown-implant part, spatial coordinates anchoring the crown’s occlusal contacts with the implant’s central axis and reference plane were integrated in a mathematical model spreadsheet. Loads of 500 N in total were selectively distributed over identified occlusal contacts from wear patterns. The resulting bending and torsion moments, the corresponding shear strength, tensile strength, maximum principal stress and von Mises stress were calculated. Fractographic analyzes were performed for all samples.           

RESULTS
Implants fractured from the periphery of the smaller inner diameter between two threads at the bone-entrance level except for one implant which failed half-way within the bone. The porous coating (AXIS Biodental) and the large grit alumina sandblasting (Z-System) created surface defects directly related to the fracture origin. The model spreadsheet showed how occlusal loading with respect to the implant’s central axis affects bending moments and crack onset. Dominant loads distributed on contacts with important wear pattern provided a calculated crack onset location in good agreement with the fractographic findings of the fracture origin. 

CONCLUSIONS 
From the data of this study it can be concluded that the occlusal load influences the position of the beginning clinical fracture in zirconium implants.     

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS
Recovered broken zirconia implant parts with their restorative crowns can provide not only information regarding the failure origin using fractography but also knowledge regarding occlusal crown loading with respect to the implant’s axis. 


For additional informations:
Translational research on clinically failed zirconia implants.

Related articles

Nowadays patients with fully edentulous maxilla may benefit from different prosthetic rehabilitations. One of them  is the implant-supported overdenture...


The edentulous posterior maxillary region often presents with unique challenging conditions in implant dentistry. Limited bone height secondary to...


Is it better to try to preserve a dental element with every possible means or to place an osseointegrated implant? There is a great variability of response...


Implant osseointegration takes several months at a minimum, and in these months oral function temporarily worsens and patients suffer during the healing...


In partially edentulous areas, implantology now has a widely established success even in the long term, but the result is influenced by operator-dependent factors that mainly concern the surgical...


Read more

From October 1st to 5th the annual meeting of the Academy of Dental Materials (ADM) was held in Jackson Hole (Wyoming, USA), entitled: "Materials to...


From October 1st to 5th the annual meeting of the Academy of Dental Materials was held in Jackson Hole (Wyoming, USA), entitled: "Materials to Enable the Evolution/Revolution of Digital...


Authors: M. Gobbo, G. Ottaviani, K. Rupel, M. Biasotto

A female patient was sent to the Medicine and Oral Pathology clinic of the Dental Clinic of Trieste for the evaluation of an intensely radiopaque foreign body...


Root caries results from the dissolution of minerals in dentine by the acids produced by bacteria, since dentine have a much lower mineral content when compared...


Tooth autotransplantation is the transplantation of one's own tooth from one site of the mouth to another edentulous site. This technique is possible only when a donor tooth is available....


 
 

Newsletter

 
 
 
 

Most popular

 
 

Events